Article: Medical paternalism and the fetus

The relationship between a pregnant mother considering a termination and the doctor should be an expert-expert one

In 2001 I published an academic article on the ethics of abortion in the Journal of Medical Ethics.

Abstract

A number of developments in the medical field have changed the debate about the ethics of abortion. These developments include: advances in fetal physiology, the increase in neonatal intensive care and the survival rates of premature infants. This paper discusses the idea of selective termination and the effects that these decisions have on disabled people of today. It presents a critique of the counselling services that are provided for the parents of a disabled fetus and discusses how this is viewed from a social perspective. The article ends with an argument that the mother deserves to be autonomous in the decision of abortion. The easiest and most fair way to develop her autonomy is to consider the relationship between a professional and a mother as an expert–expert relationship. Here both parties are considered experts in diagnostic information, treatment options, possibilities, and their history, family roots, philosophy and way of life, respectively.

Click here to read the full article or click here to download a PDF.

Leave a Reply

Tags
Most read posts
What can we learn from how the early church lived out their faith during their own pandemics?
Navigating the transitions of later life
How are young people different to those who came before, and what can we learn from them?
Living faithfully as we approach retirement, dependence, dementia and death
Investing in the next generation - Lessons from John Stott and others
Recent posts
There may be no straightforward way to turn around a struggling health service
Assisted suicide: Euthanasia tourism takes off in the US amid fresh push to change law in Britain
Innocence and guilt, partial evidence, and living with unknowns
Capacities, calling, relationships - disentangling this foundational theological tenet
The long and sad history of medical trial scandals gains another sobering chapter